← Back
Crime Junkie June 25, 2026 2m

Months Later... Evidence Suddenly Appeared #crimejunkies #truecrimeshorts #truecrimeinvestigation

Read full transcript 2 segments
  1. Months after Brittany Wallachank Months after Brittany Wallachank disappeared, a piece of evidence disappeared, a piece of evidence disappeared, a piece of evidence surfaced that should have answered one surfaced that should have answered one surfaced that should have answered one of the biggest questions in this case. of the biggest questions in this case. of the biggest questions in this case. But instead, it created a whole new But instead, it created a whole new But instead, it created a whole new mystery. One of the biggest unanswered mystery. One of the biggest unanswered mystery. One of the biggest unanswered questions in Brittany's disappearance questions in Brittany's disappearance questions in Brittany's disappearance was simple, who was she with that night? was simple, who was she with that night? was simple, who was she with that night? Because we know Brittany borrowed her Because we know Brittany borrowed her Because we know Brittany borrowed her boyfriend Sheldon Ashbrook's car. We boyfriend Sheldon Ashbrook's car. We boyfriend Sheldon Ashbrook's car. We know she left his house sometime between know she left his house sometime between know she left his house sometime between 5:00 and 6:00 p.m. And we know she 5:00 and 6:00 p.m. And we know she 5:00 and 6:00 p.m. And we know she eventually showed up at her eventually showed up at her eventually showed up at her grandmother's house with a mystery man grandmother's house with a mystery man grandmother's house with a mystery man no one could identify. But what happened no one could identify. But what happened no one could identify. But what happened in between? That's where this receipt in between? That's where this receipt in between? That's where this receipt comes in. At some point after Brittany comes in. At some point after Brittany comes in. At some point after Brittany disappeared, investigators got disappeared, investigators got disappeared, investigators got photographs of a gas receipt. The photographs of a gas receipt. The photographs of a gas receipt. The receipt was from November 30th, 2018, receipt was from November 30th, 2018, receipt was from November 30th, 2018, the exact night Brittany vanished. And the exact night Brittany vanished. And the exact night Brittany vanished. And it's timestamped 6:11 p.m. It's from a it's timestamped 6:11 p.m. It's from a it's timestamped 6:11 p.m. It's from a Marathon gas station on Fond du Lac Marathon gas station on Fond du Lac Marathon gas station on Fond du Lac River Road. And according to people River Road. And according to people River Road. And according to people close to the investigation, the receipt close to the investigation, the receipt close to the investigation, the receipt appeared tied to Brittany. Sheldon had appeared tied to Brittany. Sheldon had appeared tied to Brittany. Sheldon had previously told investigators Brittany previously told investigators Brittany previously told investigators Brittany called him that night complaining that called him that night complaining that called him that night complaining that there wasn't enough gas in the car. So there wasn't enough gas in the car. So there wasn't enough gas in the car. So this receipt could help confirm part of this receipt could help confirm part of this receipt could help confirm part of her route. But the way police got the her route. But the way police got the her route. But the way police got the receipt is where things get weird.

  2. receipt is where things get weird. receipt is where things get weird. Because investigators didn't find the Because investigators didn't find the Because investigators didn't find the receipt. It somehow ended up with receipt. It somehow ended up with receipt. It somehow ended up with someone Brittany knew someone Brittany knew someone Brittany knew named Ashley. Ashley Hooley. And named Ashley. Ashley Hooley. And named Ashley. Ashley Hooley. And according to Ashley, months after according to Ashley, months after according to Ashley, months after Brittany disappeared, her own vehicle Brittany disappeared, her own vehicle Brittany disappeared, her own vehicle was stolen and later recovered. was stolen and later recovered. was stolen and later recovered. And inside was a garbage bag full of And inside was a garbage bag full of And inside was a garbage bag full of random junk. Ashley says while sorting random junk. Ashley says while sorting random junk. Ashley says while sorting through the garbage bag, she found the through the garbage bag, she found the through the garbage bag, she found the receipt. receipt. receipt. And here's where her explanation gets And here's where her explanation gets And here's where her explanation gets interesting because in one version of interesting because in one version of interesting because in one version of events, Ashley says she didn't realize events, Ashley says she didn't realize events, Ashley says she didn't realize the receipt mattered until after it had the receipt mattered until after it had the receipt mattered until after it had been thrown away. But when we spoke with been thrown away. But when we spoke with been thrown away. But when we spoke with her directly, Ashley gave a slightly her directly, Ashley gave a slightly her directly, Ashley gave a slightly different explanation. different explanation. different explanation. She said she absolutely noticed the date She said she absolutely noticed the date She said she absolutely noticed the date and immediately felt it might be and immediately felt it might be and immediately felt it might be connected to Brittany. Maybe the receipt connected to Brittany. Maybe the receipt connected to Brittany. Maybe the receipt is meaningless, maybe it's just a weird is meaningless, maybe it's just a weird is meaningless, maybe it's just a weird coincidence. But if Brittany really coincidence. But if Brittany really coincidence. But if Brittany really stopped for gas at 6:11 that night, how stopped for gas at 6:11 that night, how stopped for gas at 6:11 that night, how would someone else have ended up with would someone else have ended up with would someone else have ended up with her receipt?

Summary

The disappearance of Brittany Wallachank is complicated by a gas receipt that surfaced months later. This receipt, dated the night Brittany vanished, was found in a stolen vehicle belonging to a woman named Ashley, who provided conflicting accounts of how she discovered it. The receipt's mysterious origin raises questions about Brittany's timeline and who was with her that night.

View original episode ↗